Petty's Purist LotR Edits [2]

Not to fret Mrs Figg- anyone that can handle eels with just cunning can master this no trouble at all.

Step one- send me your email by pm.
If have done this previously you should already have an email from me with a link to the skydrive files.
If you no longer have it or havent given me your email before, now is the time!

Ringdrotten- can you still access the second skydrive with books 5 and 6 on it? Kafria couldnt and I am having, problems.

Works fine for me

mmm. Could you pm me the details please- a link and whatever name its under- been that long I may be trying to access the wrong one!

Done

Thanks- still having problems but I fear these are buckie related!

thanks Petty I cant wait to watch it, and its in English this time the italian dubbing was nothing like the original Gandalf voice.

italian dubbing.... :S

yes I watched it with Italian dubbing, seeing as I live in Italy.

that sounds awful. not living in italy, but italian dub..

yeah its just not the same.

this is the Music Score for anyone interested.

I dunno, I thought the Italian Bilbo Baggins voice was alright. Italian Gollum was pretty terrible though.

I had fun trying to figure out what they were saying based on recollections of the trailer in English and various Italian words and phrases my mom used to say to us (she's from an Italian family). Bilbo yelling "Aspetta!" made me smile since I used to hear that one a lot.

yes Bilbo is well done, but Gandalf is nothing like Sir Ian. and Thorin is called Thorin Scudodiquercia. Its not very poetic sounding.

Well might be a better quality cut of Th purist edition sooner than expected- the oscar 'for you consideration' dvd has been leaked.

what does that last bit mean? whats for your consideration?

Interesting! Nice of someone.....

Mrs F, for a film to be considered for an Academy Award, it has to be reviewed and nominated by the Academy members, Can;t expect them to buy their own theater tickets, so the studios make special super-secret DVDs for them, Should be extremely good sound and image quality, but still the theatrical edit,

The good news

Editing is progressing on the oscar dvd.
Quality is significantly better than previous- being about dvd quality.

The bad
Its in xvid format- which means its too compresed for my editor to make use of- well the sound is anyway- this has meant I have had to create a seperate mp3 soundtrack and them match sound to visuals as I go- not only annoying fiddly work, but very time consuming, especially as the playback of the xvid in my editor is not great as it has to decode as it plays, making it jumpy on playback in the editor making the task of lining up sound to visuals all the harder.

Its seriously watermarked- way more than any other of these oscar dvds Ive ever seen. 'for your consideration' style stuff pops up regularly all over the screen (you think that would be so annoying it would effect your opinion of th efilm if you were sent it to judge)- whoever has ripped it has tried to remove these by blurring them out, which is much better than annoying writing but still leaves annoying blurs.


So in short- it will be a better quality edit than the current one and hopefully smoother in the editing- but you might want to wait till after you have bought the EE's for you collection before bothering.

well, with those watermarks, no wonder the oscars are well... you know.

Right finsihed editing TH to my satisfaction (well ok close to it) except one cut- yup one single cut I cant get right and its driving me mad.
Its right after Thorin appears at Bag End and Gandalf introduces him- Im trying to lose the line about can Bilbo use a sword- why is Thorin even asking this? Dwarves know about hobbits their main route to the mountains go right through the Shire, and Bilbo is being hired as a burglar not a warrior of some sort. Like calling in a plumber then asking him if he can do roof tiling.

Anyway bloody PJ has left me one Bilbo reaction shot short. All I need is one shot of Bilbo to put inbetween Thorin saying "so this is the hobbit." and "He looks more like a grocer than a burglar" and there isnt one anywhere in the scene or surrounds I can use- making a nasty cut- and only way not to have it is to leave the offending line in where it will make me crabbit every time I watch.

oh poor you and all this time I am waiting for AWARD SHOWS!!!! dammit Janet!

wasting your time on Hobbits when you could be doing something useful like entertaining the troops.

Pettytyrant101 wrote:Right finsihed editing TH to my satisfaction (well ok close to it) except one cut- yup one single cut I cant get right and its driving me mad.
Its right after Thorin appears at Bag End and Gandalf introduces him- Im trying to lose the line about can Bilbo use a sword- why is Thorin even asking this? Dwarves know about hobbits their main route to the mountains go right through the Shire, and Bilbo is being hired as a burglar not a warrior of some sort. Like calling in a plumber then asking him if he can do roof tiling.

Anyway bloody PJ has left me one Bilbo reaction shot short. All I need is one shot of Bilbo to put inbetween Thorin saying "so this is the hobbit." and "He looks more like a grocer than a burglar" and there isnt one anywhere in the scene or surrounds I can use- making a nasty cut- and only way not to have it is to leave the offending line in where it will make me crabbit every time I watch.

yh but it is like a cook in the army. still needs training in case the worst happens
bilbo is going into the wild
home is behind the world is ahead

but it is like a cook in the army. still needs training in case the worst happens-CC

Basically yes.

I prefer to think of it as a complete pain in the arse- trying to align a soundtrack to playback that onlys plays about 1 in ever 5 frames is not much fun, especially for one prone to occasional crabbitness

so y r u losing the line abt bilbo using a sword ?

Not losing no, lost- its gone.