All New Who

Chibnall will be a fresh start. I must say that my interest in Who has reached rock bottom, I haven't even bothered to watch this season past the first 2 episodes, anyway, criticisms of Moffat get shut down immediately, so why bother commenting? I am hoping for a reawakening in my interest, but at the moment there are far more interesting shows out there. Its a bad do if we argue about an innocent comment about someone deactivating their comments section on Youtube.
I am sorry if Petty feels offended, it wasn't meant on my part anyway, even though I found him a bit insensitive and didn't like it when he did a character assassination on Jenny, which isn't fair. She is the least likely person on the internet to be rude and aggressive.
Anyway I apologize, for what its worth.

Deborah Watling who played The Second Doctor companion Victoria Waterfield has passed away aged 69:

http://www.clactonandfrintongazette.co.uk/news/north_essex_news/15426589.Actress_Deborah_Watling__who_played_Doctor_Who_s_second_assistant__has_died__aged_69/

In less sad news:

http://www.denofgeek.com/us/tv/doctor-who/266484/classic-doctor-who-lost-episodes-coming-to-britbox

Peter Davison's thoughts on the 13th Doctor casting:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/07/21/former-doctor-peter-davison-says-female-choice-role-means-loss/

Colin Baker on Peter Capaldi:

http://www.digitalspy.com/tv/doctor-who/news/a833641/colin-baker-doctor-who-fans-not-kind-peter-capaldi/

Hi Figgy. I hope you don't think I was trying to shut down conversation. But hopefully hinting that taking a breath might be good idea. Old wounds never actually heal and can reopen at times. When they do, I think at some point someone tries to put a bandage on the wound to let it close over again. The wound will always exist regards Moffatt. So I'm thinking, when it has clearly opened again, we just say: okay, chill time. This is a tv show after all. Nothing wrong with passion. But when people start getting angry at each other - and I point no fault here; this is one of those unproveable things, and pointless trying - then it's time to step back and take a breath. Make love not war and all that, man. (Actually, having read back through the thread, I can see the points all three of you are making. It really is a question of different perspectives. That's all. But there you go. )

its a good thing this wasn't actually about Moffat this time then. It could have been worse.

You know, what is it about Who? Are Trekkians as volatile?

I am sure there are dangerous topics among the trekkies too. If they are as dangerous as Moffat and Amy and Rose though...

Forumshirans have never been anything if not feisty.

I am sure there are dangerous topics among the trekkies too. If they are as dangerous as Moffat and Amy and Rose though...

Wesley Crusher.

Eru have mercy!

debating the merits of Kirk vs Picard.

... and there's the rebooted ST...

Spock vs. Data

How about we drop these off as tropic starters at the ST thread?

if this doesn't get Petty back here pronto, nothing will. call it crabbit therapy.    

I'm heading to the crabbit bunker.

  this merits x2

{{ You are safe I already gave my views on it- but do check out the comments on that vid, just sort under 'top comments' my thoughts are in their somewhere. But if I had to give a one word description of that vid it would be- 'sloppy'.

Heres some more interesting vids from comic-con }}

I didn't see anything in the youtube comments section that was obviously you.

Petty's back

{{{Halfy if you filter the comments by 'top comments' it should be the first one immediately below the OP's sticky comment. }}

AH good old Doctor Who discussion.
 

Pettytyrant101 wrote:{{{Halfy if you filter the comments by 'top comments' it should be the first one immediately below the OP's sticky comment. }}

What, the little 3 sentence response? That couldn't have been you.

{{Um definitely not- shouldn't be hard to find you know- I use the same username and same avatar as here Bloody hairball }}}